Your customers want simplicity, not features

I was extremely amused by a story I saw today about the new Droid smart phone offered by Verizon. I always get mildly amused when I see the next “iPhone killer” but this one in particular got my attention because of the direct head-to-head challenge to the iPhone as seen in this teaser commercial.

Is the commercial cute and a little bit clever? Sure. Is it going to make people buy the Droid instead of the iPhone? I doubt it.

I don’t understand why the Verizon, Motorola, and all the other players in the industry simply continue to remain oblivious. What they (and most companies, for that matter) don’t get is that features do not sell products.

Now I realize that this is a generalization and that there are some cases where features do indeed make a difference but on the whole, it’s not about features. It’s about how your product enhances the life of your customer.

The problem is that most engineers design products for other engineers. Technology-driven people like features. They read manuals and compare features and get excited over technical specs. The rest of us don’t care. The rest of us want something that’s easy to use.

The Droid boasts lots of features that the iPhone doesn’t have. Guess what? Nobody cares. Does my mother care that the Droid has a “real” keyboard? Nope… the iPhone’s software keyboard seems to work just fine. Does my neighbor care that the Droid takes 5-megapixel photos? Nope… what’s wrong with the iPhone’s photos? They look just fine on Facebook. Does my co-worker care that the Droid runs widgets? Huh? What’s a widget?

Guess what the iPhone does that the Droid doesn’t? It enhances your life by being simple. The iPhone is pretty, shiny, colorful, and easy to use. Want to make a call? Press the big green button and you’re only a few clicks away from any phone-related function. Want to check email? Press the big jelly-filled envelope. Want to get on Facebook? Look! There’s a big bubbly icon for that!

Additionally, how many moving parts does the iPhone have that could potentially break? One: the big round “home” button. The rest of the phone is basically one smooth unit with no other moving parts. It’s hard to break something that self-contained.

What most engineers and the companies that employ them fail to realize is that the vast majority of people do not care about a long list of fancy features. They want technology to make their lives simpler, easier, and more productive. They want to accomplish simple things and then they want the technology to get out of the way so they can get on with their lives.

In fact, people will often avoid buying a product if it appears too complicated. What’s the best way to make a product look complicated? Show off a long list of features.

Whether it’s a consumer product, a piece of software, or a website, people want simplicity. They want your product or service to make their lives easier and simpler. This is why “iPhone killers” continue to miss the mark.

  • http://tribeswell.com Colin Clark

    I agree with you 100%

    I also think that one of the really big reasons why the iphone is so widespread is that it is a communication platform that lots of people want to be a part of. No one gets that jealous of the palm pre. I think the android phones are kind of cool, but I'm not trading in my iphone.

    As soon as you first see an iphone you kind of want one. As more and more people adopt the technology, demand increases. Now when someone I know gets an iphone i get excited. Another member has joined the tribe.

    The other phone companies are stupid to try to produce iphone 'killers'. No one will succeed. They should focus on generating value in new markets.

    My suggestion would be to try to own the netbook (with 3g inside) market or small tablets that are cheap and really easy to use.

    They need to reread Blue Ocean Strategy and stop trying to copy apple.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/tobiasly tobiasly

    Mike, I had posted a reply to this a while back but it either got marked as spam or my Android phone didn't post it correctly :) (It said it was being held for moderation…)

    Anyway, I think you're really projecting here. Verizon isn't going after the people who are already really happy with their iPhone. You're right, there's probably not much they can do to win them over. They're going after the people like me — and there are a lot more of them than you think — who tried out the iPhone and weren't impressed, or who maybe even bought an iPhone when it first came out, generally liked it, but are looking for something else.

    I really admire, congratulate, and am grateful for Apple for redefining the smartphone market and kicking BlackBerry, Windows Mobile, Palm etc. from their comfortable, complacent perch. But I really just wasn't as impressed by the iPhone as most everyone else. I realize I'm not a typical consumer, but I challenge you to back up your "vast majority of people" claim.

    Go out and read this post from TechCrunch (and watch the video) about the Google Maps Navigation that will be on Verizon's Droid and then repeat your claim that users don't want features:

    http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/10/28/google-redef…

    Those features alone already makes the phone worth more than the standalone GPS unit I bought for significantly more money. My Sprint HTC Hero Android phone is exactly what I was looking for in a smartphone, and HTC's Sense UI is amazing. Blows anything the iPhone can do out of the water.

    My wife tried and didn't care for the iPhone, but really loves her Palm Pre. She has an iPod with iTunes and liked it at first, until the 3rd of 4th time the supposedly uber-intuitive software deleted her entire music library. Then she became jealous of watching me drag and drop music files to my MP3 player without iTunes, so I'll admit she is a bit suspicious of Apple products from that experience.

    So yes, I agree with you that just slapping a bunch of features on a phone with poor execution (something a lot of companies have been doing since the iPhone came out) will not convert anyone over. But flat out claiming that users don't care for features is crazy.

    Every time I show people how my Android phone automatically and seamlessly integrates my Facebook friend data with my Google Contacts data (so calling or texting someone shows their profile pic, or pulling up their contact card shows their birthday, status updates, albums etc.) the luster of the iPhone goes down a bit.

    iPhone's motto is "there's an app for that", but with my phone, it's all built directly in. I don't have to switch from a Facebook app to the dialer app to the Contacts app. And everyone I've shown it to has loved it. So again, I very much disagree that people don't care about features. They do want features, they just want them to be done in the right way.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/mbreyno mbreyno

    Toby,

    Thanks for the comments! You make some really good points here. I may be projecting, but hey… it's my blog :)

    I have yet to see an Android phone in real life so perhaps my opinion of "other phones" will improve once I see it in action. Thanks for adding value to the conversation!

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/tobiasly tobiasly

      Well let me know next time you're in town and you can see one in real life :)

      We got a Droid at work this week for testing mobile sites and WOW is the screen just AMAZING. I have never seen such pixel density on anything before. Even the tiniest font type is incredibly crisp, and the detail in Google Maps sat view is crazy. Blows both of our phones away!

      And the Google Navigation stuff… again, WOW. It's a game-changer (for GPSes, not necessarily for phones, though it certainly raises the bar). You have to check it out. I'll never buy a standalone GPS again.

      Anyway, hope to see you at some point over the holidays so we can talk about phones and stuff :)