Ok, so I think everyone knows my take on QR codes by now. I think they have very useful applications in some contexts, but I am frustrated to see so many marketers acting like they should be used to push more marketing at people.
Just to prove that I’m not a QR-hater, here is an interesting story of how the Wall Street Journal got it right. This is an outstanding use of QR because they identified the context as appropriate for QR (someone sitting down with a newspaper) and they encouraged sharing, rather than pushing more marketing. Brilliant!
However, for every great example of QR code usage, there are a million (made-up statistic) examples of poor usage. For example, I often get postcards in the mail that feature a big shiny QR code on it. Next to the code, it usually says something like “scan this code for a special message!” Hmmm… is that really a good conversion system?
Let’s analyze this. First, where do most people receive these postcards? Yep, at their offices. Next, where do most people typically sort through the mail? Yep, at a desk (with a trash can nearby). Finally, what is usually sitting on that desk? You guessed it… a computer! Now, if I have a postcard in my hand while I’m sitting at my computer, why would I pull out my phone, open an app (that I may or may not have on my phone already), carefully scan this little box, and then look at the tiny screen on my phone while it pulls up some content? Wouldn’t it be easier to just turn to my computer and type in a website address in a full browser?
Aside from incorrectly assessing the context of the recipient, the other issue is that most of the postcards I receive simply encourage me to scan the QR code just to get more marketing. What’s my incentive? Why not offer me something of value instead and clearly explain it? What is a “special message?”
Before jumping on the shiny QR bandwagon, I think it’s important to answer two questions:
- Is QR the easiest way for my constituents to get this information in the context that they will be getting my message?
- What is their incentive to ask for it?
Sometimes the answer to the first question is yes, which means you can happily QR to your heart’s content. However, let’s stop using QR codes because we can. Let’s start using them because we should.

